Overtraining in football: how to spot the warning signs
Learn how to spot overtraining and a lack of recovery in your players and how to track fatigue with simple questionnaires and no technology.
How do I spot overtraining in my players?
Overtraining rarely announces itself with a single signal. What is typical is a combination of persistent tiredness, low mood, poor sleep and declining performance over several weeks, even though training is normal. Frequent infections and minor injuries often come on top. A single bad day, on the other hand, is normal and no cause for concern.
The good news: true overtraining is rare in amateur football. Much more common is overload over a few days or weeks, because training, matches, school or work, too little sleep and private stress come together. The best way to spot it is to ask your players regularly how they are doing. You do not need lab values or expensive measuring devices for this.
Overload, overreaching, overtraining: what is the difference?
- Normal fatigue: After a match or a hard session you are tired for one to three days. This is intended, without fatigue there is no adaptation (see Supercompensation).
- Short-term overload: Several hard days in a row or too little sleep. Performance drops for a few days, and after a few quieter days everything is fine again.
- Overtraining: Performance drops over weeks or months, and even breaks of one to two weeks bring no quick improvement. This is a medical problem and belongs in a doctor's hands.
The transition is gradual. The earlier you take countermeasures, the sooner the players are fit again.
The most important warning signs
The first signs often show in behaviour, even before performance drops:
- irritability, listlessness, bad mood
- trouble concentrating, more mistakes in simple tasks
- players are slow to get going, the warm-up feels sluggish
Later, physical signs are added:
- poor sleep despite tiredness
- little appetite, weight loss
- frequent colds and other infections
- muscle soreness or heavy legs that no longer go away
- minor injuries and strains become more frequent
- performance in matches fluctuates widely or declines
No single sign proves anything. What matters is when several come together and persist over a longer period. Anyone who is tired and run down for weeks should also be examined by a doctor, because a cold that was never properly shaken off, iron deficiency or another illness can also be behind it.
Measuring fatigue: why there is no perfect test
In professional football, blood values, heart rate variability, jump tests and GPS data are collected. Even so, there is no single value that reliably shows whether a player has recovered. Blood markers such as creatine kinase vary widely from player to player. Heart rate variability needs the same measuring conditions every day.
Studies and practice therefore reach the same conclusion: simple questionnaires are at least as informative as expensive measurements, cost nothing and take seconds.
Three simple tools for coaches
1. Ask about effort after training
After the session, have every player say on a scale from 0 to 10 how strenuous it was. 0 means “not at all”, 10 means “maximal, I could not have done more”. Important: only ask about half an hour after training, otherwise the last drill determines the verdict.
Multiplied by the duration of the session, this gives the training load. A 90-minute session rated 6 gives 540. If the total suddenly rises sharply from one week to the next, the risk of overload rises too.
2. Ask about wellbeing before training
Before training, briefly ask how the players are. This works with a slip of paper or a poll on the phone, each on a scale from 1 (very bad) to 5 (very good):
- How well did you sleep?
- How tired do you feel?
- How bad is your muscle soreness?
- What is your mood like?
- How much stress did you have (school, work, private life)?
The German statutory accident insurer VBG suggests an even simpler form: each player anonymously gives two scores, one for the body and one for the mind. This produces an average for the team that shows how fit the team as a whole is at the moment.
3. Watch trends, not single values
One bad score on one day is normal. What matters are changes over several days: a player who normally always gives a “4” and has only given a “2” for two weeks needs a conversation. Then ask about sleep, school or work, stress and health before you talk about training.
What to do if a player is overloaded?
- Reduce the load: less intensity, shorter sessions, if in doubt a few days off or a break from matches.
- Look for causes: sleep, nutrition, stress outside football, too many matches (for example in several teams at the same time).
- Strengthen the basics: more sleep, regular meals, enough fluids. What matters after a match is covered in the article Recovery after a match.
- Have it checked by a doctor if the symptoms last longer than two weeks or infections keep coming back.
- Return slowly: increase volume first, then intensity.
How to prevent it
- Plan the week with a clear rhythm of load and recovery (see Planning a training week).
- Increase the load step by step, especially after the summer and winter breaks.
- With young players, pay particular attention to the total load: school sport, club training, representative squads and a second sport all add up.
- Talk to your players. Those who know that tiredness is not a sign of weakness will also say so.
You can keep an eye on your players' attendance and load in bolzn.
Sources
- Meeusen, R. et al. (2013). Prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of the overtraining syndrome: joint consensus statement of the ECSS and the ACSM. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 45(1), 186–205.
- Saw, A. E., Main, L. C. & Gastin, P. B. (2016). Monitoring the athlete training response: subjective self-reported measures trump commonly used objective measures. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(5), 281–291.
- Foster, C. et al. (2001). A new approach to monitoring exercise training. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 15(1), 109–115.
- VBG (2017). Diagnostik & Betreuung im Fußball – Leistungsdiagnostik und Verletzungsprävention. Hamburg.
- Abaïdia, A.-E. & Dupont, G. (2018). Recovery strategies for football players. Swiss Sports & Exercise Medicine, 66(4), 28–36.